Politics In Character & Fitness Decisions

April 20, 2006 - William Hanlon has never been convicted of any crime.  However, 25 years ago, as a young police officer, Hanlon participated in a cover-up after fellow police officers engaged in a beating death of a black motorcyclist.   The facts and circumstances of Hanlon’s participation in the 25-year-old event can be found by clicking here.

The Florida Board of Bar Examiners and the Florida Supreme Court allowed Hanlon to initially apply for a license to practice law, get denied, wait through two years of ineligibility, reapply for admission, get denied again by the Board, and then today, be told by the Florida Supreme Court that he is forever barred from reapplying.  Click here to see the Florida Supreme Court Order.  The Board’s and the Court’s unconscionable actions offend the basic concepts of due process.  

We know that concern for the rights of someone who has committed a horrendous act 25 years ago is not politically popular, but our Founding Fathers enacted the Constitution and expected its clear intent to be followed. Regardless of how politically unpopular a person is, he should not be denied the right to earn a living in his chosen profession on account of political considerations.  The Florida Supreme Court has, once again, abandoned the external pretence of honor by allowing improper and outside influences to tilt the scales of justice. 

FloridaBarWatch is encouraging Hanlon to file a Section 1983 lawsuit, similar to that filed by FloridaBarWatch’s attorney Dennis Dubuc, including a claim for damages.  (Click here to see the Dubuc opinion). 

 

BELOW IS THE VIDEO OF THE ORAL ARGUMENT IN HANLON’S CASE:  

Click here to see the Florida Supreme Court struggle to get FBBE General Counsel Thomas Pobjecky to simply answer the question "what more could Mr. Hanlon have done" to show his rehabilitation?  (Click on Media Player for case # 04-185, Florida Board of Bar Examiners Re: W.F.H.)